Insights

Not every AI tool needs a committee

When everything needs approval, nothing moves, and people find their own way round. Match the level of oversight to the level of risk.
17 Sep 2026
AI, Risk and governance
A ring of dark dots on thin spokes around a single blue dot at the centre, the spokes stopping short of it.

Match oversight to risk. Basic rules for everyday use, a short review for moderate risk, real scrutiny for anything touching people's money, jobs or rights. Use the boards and checks you already have rather than a new committee, and remember the biggest risk is the unofficial tools nobody approved.

Plenty of organisations respond to AI by setting up a new committee. Every idea goes to it. Every tool waits for it. And while it meets once a month, people across the business get on with using whatever they can find.

When everything needs approval, nothing moves. That doesn’t make anyone safer.

The risk you're not looking at

In most organisations I’ve worked with, the biggest AI risk isn’t in the proposals queuing for approval. It’s in the work already happening without one. Customer data pasted into free tools. Spreadsheets doing jobs they were never built for. Personal accounts used because the official route takes too long.

Slow governance doesn’t stop that. It encourages it.

Three levels are usually enough

A more useful approach is to match the oversight to the risk. Three levels work for most organisations.

The first is a set of basic rules that apply to everyone, all the time. Use approved tools. Keep customer and confidential data out of anything that isn’t approved. A person stays responsible for anything that goes out. Say when AI was used. That covers a large share of everyday use, and it needs no meeting at all.

The second is a standard review for tools that carry moderate risk. Internal use, no decisions about individuals, a clear owner. A short form, a named reviewer, a decision within days.

The third is closer oversight for anything that affects people’s money, jobs, rights or legal position. Credit decisions, recruitment, debt recovery, anything a customer might want to challenge. This is where the real time and expertise should go.

The government’s new AI Risk Management Toolkit takes a similar line, asking organisations to set a clear appetite for each type of risk rather than one blanket position on AI. It says plainly that without that clarity, teams run into blockers that “will eventually stifle innovation”.

Use the people you already have

You probably don’t need a new committee. You need existing people with clearer jobs.

Most organisations already have change boards, data protection reviews, security checks and risk registers. Add AI to them rather than building something alongside. Set the standards centrally, and let the teams closest to the work apply them. Bring legal and data protection in at the start. If they only see an AI tool when it’s ready to launch, governance has arrived too late.

Reuse what you can. A good data protection impact assessment for your first AI tool can become the template for the next five. Work that took weeks the first time should take days after that.

The questions don't scale with the price

The size of the contract is a poor guide to the level of risk. A cheap tool that screens job applicants can do far more harm than an expensive one that summarises board papers.

Whatever the cost, three questions apply. Where does the person sit: approving every output, reviewing samples, or not involved at all? What is the data really like, rather than what the vendor assumes? And who answers when it’s wrong?

If those have clear answers, most tools can move quickly. If they don’t, no amount of committee time will make the tool safe.

Keep a record of what the tool did and who approved it. If something goes wrong, that record is your defence.

Where to start

List the AI tools already in use across the business, including the unofficial ones. Sort them into the three levels. You’ll probably find most sit in the first, a handful in the second, and very few in the third. Put your effort where the risk is.

Is your governance slowing the safe work and missing the risky stuff?

Let’s map what’s already in use across the business and put the oversight where the risk actually is.

Share this insight

Related insights
A faint grid of binary zeros and ones on cream, with a single blue magnifying glass to the right.
AI, Digital

Scotland’s biggest law firms have cracked SEO. Almost none are ready for AI search.

Scotland’s biggest law firms have cracked SEO, but almost none are ready for AI search. What we found across the ten largest firms, and the five fixes that move a firm from invisible to quotable.
2 Oct 2026
Three nested rounded frames on a cream ground, scattered with dark dots and rings, a few of them picked out in blue.
Marketing, Risk and governance

The riskiest AI in your marketing team is the tool nobody approved

How marketing teams can use AI without breaking data-protection rules or brand trust. Right-size the oversight, name an owner, and start with the tools already in use.
29 Sep 2026
Many tangled dark lines, two of them blue, drawn together from the left into one straight line that ends in a single dot.
AI, Marketing

Before AI optimises your campaigns, fix what you’re measuring

AI can optimise campaigns and share credit across channels, but only if the data underneath is joined up and honest. How to get attribution AI can actually use.
28 Sep 2026

Let's grab a coffee.

If something's stuck, or you'd like a second opinion on a plan, tell me about it. No hard sell.