If you’re sitting in the C-suite right now, the pressure to buy AI is real, and it’s coming from every direction. Customers are starting to expect it. Competitors are being loud about having it. And not being able to point to your own AI story can start to feel like a disadvantage, whether or not it actually is one.
So I understand why a lot of the conversations I’ve had with CEOs, CMOs and CFOs over the past few weeks begin with a product already in mind. The instinct to act is the right one. It’s the order that trips people up.
Here’s the pattern I keep seeing. A competitor makes an announcement, the board asks what we’re doing about AI, and within a few weeks there’s a tool being evaluated before anyone has written down the problem it’s meant to solve. The pressure is genuine. But buying first and finding the problem later is where the money goes.
None of this is new. You would never sign off a major change programme or a big system spend without a clear business case. Finance wouldn’t allow it, and nor would the board. AI deserves the same discipline. The difference is that AI punishes a weak business case faster than anything else you’ve bought.
The speed of change is brutal. A tool that looks sharp today can be obsolete within weeks. The thing you’re about to sign a twelve-month contract for could be something you build yourself in a fortnight once the next frontier model opens up that functionality. Or it quietly becomes redundant because it was built on a model from two years ago. So you’re not just risking a bad fit. You’re risking spend that was wasted the moment you committed to it.
The way through is less exciting than the demo, and far more reliable. Start with the problem, not the technology. Where are you actually losing value? What outcome do you need? Whose behaviour has to change to get there? What would good look like in twelve months? Those questions point you at the business, and they give you a way to judge whatever you buy.
And once the problem is clear, here’s the part a lot of vendors would rather you didn’t ask. AI is often not the answer. Plenty of the problems thrown at AI would be solved faster and cheaper by better training, a fixed process, some straightforward automation, or a system you already pay for. Going in with an AI-first attitude means you’ve chosen the answer before you’ve understood the question.
That’s the work I do with leadership teams: figure out where AI genuinely fits, where it doesn’t, and how to use it well, and then, only then, choose the product that’s right for you. Not the one a competitor bought. The one that solves a problem you can name and measure.
The pressure to move isn’t going away, and you shouldn’t ignore it. But the leaders getting real value from AI aren’t the ones who bought fastest. They’re the ones who were clear about the problem before they spent a penny.
Define the problem first. Everything after that gets a lot easier.
If you want to put this to work, I’ve turned the whole process into a free workbook — Define the problem before you buy the tool — that you can work through with your team before you speak to a single vendor.
If AI is on your agenda and you want to be sure you’re spending on the right thing, that’s the conversation to have before you sign. Ping me a message, or let’s grab a coffee.
What’s pushing AI up your agenda right now: customers, competitors, or the board?