Insights

You shouldn’t need a new CMO to ask the awkward questions

A new marketing leader finds money going to waste everywhere, not because they’re cleverer, but because they’re still allowed to ask why. Here are the questions worth asking on a routine, long before anyone new turns up.
24 Sep 2026
Marketing, Projects
A long row of identical dark squares on cream, with one square's lid lifted open to show it is blue inside.

A new leader's questions aren't clever, they're permitted. You don't need a new hire to ask them. Once a quarter, take one area, price the option of simply stopping, and aim the question at the spend and the process, not the people who inherited them.

Bring in a new head of marketing and the same thing happens every time. In the first few months they find spend nobody can quite account for, reports nobody acts on, and an agency nobody can fully explain. It looks like sharp insight. Mostly it isn’t.

They’re not seeing things the existing team couldn’t see. They’re asking questions that had quietly stopped getting asked. That’s not a failing of the people who were there. It’s how every established operation works. When an arrangement has been in place for three years, it stops looking like a choice and starts looking like the furniture. The line item that made sense in 2023 is now just part of the budget. The newcomer’s advantage isn’t intelligence. It’s that they haven’t yet absorbed which questions have become impolite to ask.

And there’s good reason the questions get buried. Marketing leaders are under real pressure to keep moving. Customers expect the brands they deal with to be visible and current. Competitors are loud about what they’re doing. The board wants to see activity. In that environment, stopping to interrogate a working arrangement feels like a luxury you can’t afford. So the spend rolls over, the retainer renews, the dashboard keeps landing in the inbox, and everyone gets on with the next campaign.

The cost of that is bigger than it looks. When Rakuten Marketing surveyed 1,000 marketers, they estimated that around a quarter of their budgets, 26% on average, went to ineffective channels and strategies. That isn’t money lost to bad decisions. It’s money lost to decisions nobody revisited. Which is the good news, because it means you don’t need a new CMO to recover it. You need the discipline to keep asking the questions yourself.

It's not the newcomer's insight, it's their permission

The questions a new leader asks aren’t clever. That’s the part worth being honest about. “What does this agency actually do for us?” isn’t a stroke of genius. It just sounds pointed coming from the person who signed the contract last year.

That’s why it tends to take an outsider. The questions carry a faint accusation, so the people closest to the spend are the least comfortable raising them. Everyone can see the awkward arrangement. Nobody wants to be the one to name it, because naming it implies they might have named it sooner. None of that is a character flaw. It’s the completely rational behaviour of people who have to work with each other on Monday.

So the real skill isn’t spotting the waste. Most teams can see it perfectly well. The skill is building a way of working where asking about it is normal and expected, and where the question lands on the arrangement rather than the person who set it up.

The questions worth asking on a routine

A handful come up in almost every marketing team, and each one deserves a proper answer more than once a year.

On reporting: do we actually know what’s working, or do we have dashboards that look busy and change nobody’s mind? A report only earns its place if a plausible answer would make you do something different. A chart that never changes a decision is just decoration.

On technology: are we using what we already pay for? This is the one that tends to shock. Gartner found that marketers use just 42% of the capabilities in the martech they already own, down from 58% two years earlier. The instinct when results are flat is to buy another tool. Often the capability you need is sitting dormant in a licence you renewed without opening.

On media: what are we still spending on because we always have? Habit is not a media strategy, and “it’s always been part of the mix” is not a reason.

On conversion: why are we buying more traffic before we’ve fixed the traffic we already pay for? Sending more people into a journey that leaks isn’t growth. It’s just spending faster.

On the CRM: did we spend real money winning a lead and then follow it up with one half-hearted email three days later? The numbers here are brutal. A Harvard Business Review analysis of 1.25 million leads found that firms responding within an hour were seven times more likely to have a meaningful conversation with a decision-maker than those that waited even an hour longer, and sixty times more likely than those who waited a day. The effort of winning attention and the effort of using it are wildly out of proportion in most teams, and the gap is measured in revenue.

On agencies: for each one, what do they do, what do they cost, and what measurable value do they add? The third question is the one that produces the long silence. It’s worth asking why that silence is tolerated. The same Gartner work made the point sharply: it’s hard to imagine leaders leaving millions on the table in an underused agency relationship the way they quietly do with underused technology. The scrutiny you’d apply to a new supplier is exactly the scrutiny the old ones have stopped getting.

On the team: who’s doing the real work, who is quietly carrying three jobs, and who has turned being busy into a full-time role of its own? Worth noting that budget pressure usually falls on headcount first and technology last, which is often exactly the wrong way round.

On strategy: can anyone explain it in a couple of sentences, without opening a slide deck? If it takes forty slides to describe, it isn’t a strategy. It’s a filing system.

None of these needs a consultant to ask. They need someone willing to sit in the discomfort of the answer.

The most expensive sentence in marketing

Behind almost all of it sits one phrase: “we’ve always done it this way.”

It’s worth being honest about how much that sentence costs, because it rarely announces itself. It has funded more unexamined sponsorships, more untouched retainers and more unread reports than any bad decision made on purpose. A bad decision at least gets challenged. “We’ve always done it this way” never does, because it doesn’t look like a decision at all. It looks like the background.

There’s a well-documented version of this in behavioural economics: the sunk-cost fallacy, the pull to keep funding something because you’ve already funded it. It’s the same instinct that keeps a gambler at the table. In a marketing budget it’s quieter and more expensive, because the thing you’re protecting isn’t money you’ll win back. It’s money you’ll keep spending.

The job isn’t to tear up everything a newcomer would. Most of what you’re doing is probably working, and change for its own sake is just a different kind of waste. The job is narrower and more useful: make sure nothing survives purely because no one remembered to ask about it.

Make it a habit, not an intervention

The reason this keeps falling to new starters is that most organisations treat the hard questions as an event. A restructure. A new hire. A review triggered by a bad quarter. Then it goes quiet again until the next crisis forces the issue.

It works far better as a routine. Once a quarter, take one area and look at it as if you’d just arrived. Price the option of simply stopping, so “carry on as we are” has to win against a real alternative instead of winning by default. Put one uncomfortable question on the agenda of a meeting that’s gone stale. And say out loud that the questions are aimed at the spend and the process, not at the people who inherited them, because if that isn’t clear, nobody will answer honestly.

Do that and you get most of the benefit a new leader brings, without the disruption, the handover, and the year it takes them to learn your business from the inside.

The best marketing leaders I’ve worked with aren’t the ones with the cleverest strategy. They’re the ones who kept the outsider’s habit of asking why, long after they stopped being the outsider. It’s a habit worth keeping on purpose.

If you suspect there are questions your team has quietly stopped asking, and you’d rather find them yourself than have a new hire find them for you, let’s talk it through. It’s the kind of thing we help marketing teams do.

Questions people ask

Why does a new marketing leader always seem to find waste?

Because they're still allowed to ask why. A newcomer hasn't yet learned which arrangements have become impolite to question, so they ask about the spend, the reports and the agencies everyone else has stopped noticing. It isn't superior insight, it's permission. The existing team can usually see the same things. They're just the least comfortable raising them.

How much of a marketing budget is typically wasted?

Marketers themselves put it at around a quarter. In a survey of 1,000 marketers by Rakuten Marketing, the average estimate of budget going to ineffective channels and strategies was 26%. The exact figure matters less than where it comes from: most of that waste is decisions nobody went back and revisited, which means it's recoverable without spending a penny more.

What questions should a marketing team ask on a routine?

Seven come up in almost every team. Do our reports actually change a decision? Are we using the technology we already pay for? What are we spending on purely out of habit? Why are we buying more traffic before fixing the traffic we have? Are we following up the leads we paid to win? What measurable value does each agency add? And can anyone explain the strategy in two sentences without opening a slide deck? Each one deserves a proper answer more than once a year.

How often should we review marketing spend and agencies?

Make it a routine, not a crisis response. Once a quarter, take one area and look at it as if you'd just arrived, pricing the option of simply stopping so "carry on as we are" has to earn its place against a real alternative. One area at a time, every quarter, is more honest and less disruptive than a big annual audit everyone braces for and games.

Why don't existing teams ask these questions themselves?

The questions carry a faint accusation. Asking "what does this agency actually do for us?" implies someone should have asked sooner, and the person closest to the spend is usually the one who approved it. That isn't a failing of character. It's the rational behaviour of people who have to work together on Monday. The fix is to make the questions normal and expected, and aim them at the arrangement rather than the person who set it up.

How do we know if we're wasting money on marketing technology?

Start by checking how much of what you own you actually use. Gartner found marketers use just 42% of the capabilities in their martech, down from 58% two years earlier. When results are flat the instinct is to buy another tool, but the capability you need is often sitting dormant in a licence you renewed without opening. Audit usage before you buy anything new.

What should we ask an agency at review time?

Three things: what do they do, what do they cost, and what measurable value do they add? The third tends to produce a long silence, and it's worth asking why that silence is tolerated when you'd never accept it from a new supplier. Hold the agencies and in-house resource you've had for years to the same standard as anything you're buying today.

What does "we've always done it this way" actually cost?

More than any deliberate bad decision, because a bad decision at least gets challenged. This is the sunk-cost fallacy in a marketing budget: funding something because you've already funded it. It quietly keeps sponsorships, retainers and reports alive long after they've stopped earning their place. The job isn't to scrap everything. It's to make sure nothing survives purely because no one remembered to ask.

Stopped asking the awkward questions?

If you suspect there are questions your team has quietly stopped asking, and you’d rather find them before a new hire does, let’s talk it through.

Share this insight

Related insights
Three nested rounded frames on a cream ground, scattered with dark dots and rings, a few of them picked out in blue.
Marketing, Risk and governance

The riskiest AI in your marketing team is the tool nobody approved

How marketing teams can use AI without breaking data-protection rules or brand trust. Right-size the oversight, name an owner, and start with the tools already in use.
29 Sep 2026
Many tangled dark lines, two of them blue, drawn together from the left into one straight line that ends in a single dot.
AI, Marketing

Before AI optimises your campaigns, fix what you’re measuring

AI can optimise campaigns and share credit across channels, but only if the data underneath is joined up and honest. How to get attribution AI can actually use.
28 Sep 2026
A neat grid of identical dark dots on cream, with one dot in blue, ringed to stand out from the rest.
AI, Marketing

Personalisation that helps, not personalisation that pesters

A practical guide to personalised lead generation and engagement with AI: the data foundation, lead scoring, guardrails, and the line between helpful and creepy.
27 Sep 2026

Let's grab a coffee.

If something's stuck, or you'd like a second opinion on a plan, tell me about it. No hard sell.